The Risks of Buying a Home With Unpermitted Renovation Work

Download
Download this document in PDF format »

Legal and Regulatory Problems

  • Code Violations:
    Unpermitted work likely fails to meet current building, electrical, plumbing, or fire safety codes.
  • Stop Work or Demolition Orders:
    The municipality can issue a stop-work order or require removal of unpermitted structures or systems.
  • Retroactive Permitting Difficulties:
    Obtaining permits after the fact (“as-built” permits) can be time-consuming, costly, and sometimes impossible if work doesn’t meet code.
  • Municipal Fines and Penalties:
    The property owner — not the previous owner — is typically liable for violations and fines.
  • Title or Zoning Issues:
    The unpermitted structure may violate zoning laws (setbacks, use restrictions, lot coverage limits, etc.) and prevent title insurance or certificates of occupancy.

Financial and Insurance Problems

  • Reduced Property Value:
    Appraisers and buyers often discount homes with undocumented work because of the risk and uncertainty.
  • Higher Costs for Compliance:
    You might have to open walls, upgrade wiring, or replace plumbing to meet current code — at your expense.
  • Insurance Coverage Denial:
    Homeowners insurance may deny claims related to unpermitted work (e.g., fire caused by unapproved electrical wiring).
  • Difficulty Refinancing or Selling:
    Lenders and future buyers may reject or delay transactions until violations are corrected and properly documented.
  • Ineligible for Certain Loans:
    FHA, VA, or other federally backed loans often require proof that all structures and systems are permitted and inspected.

Safety and Structural Problems

  • Substandard or Unsafe Construction:
    Without inspections, work may have been done by unqualified individuals — risking electrical fires, leaks, mold, or structural failure.
  • Undetected Hidden Defects:
    Hidden wiring, plumbing, or load-bearing modifications could pose long-term hazards or require invasive inspection later.
  • Increased Liability Risk:
    If a guest or future buyer is injured due to faulty work, you could face personal liability.

Disclosure and Transaction Problems

  • Failure to Disclose:
    Sellers who conceal unpermitted work can be liable for misrepresentation or fraud; however, enforcement is often burdensome for buyers.
  • Inspection Limitations:
    Home inspectors can’t issue permits or open concealed work — meaning many issues may go unnoticed until after purchase.
  • Unrecorded Additions:
    The tax assessor’s records may not reflect actual square footage or additions, leading to discrepancies in property valuation.
  • Future Resale Headaches:
    You may be forced to legalize or remove the unpermitted work before selling, delaying your transaction and lowering resale appeal.

Community and Utility Problems

  • Utility Connection Issues:
    Certain systems (e.g., HVAC, plumbing, or sewer) may not be legally tied into municipal services without permits.
  • Impact on Neighboring Properties:
    Improper grading, drainage, or expansion could violate setbacks or cause runoff issues, leading to neighbor disputes.
  • Municipal Record Problems:
    Lack of permits means the municipality has no official record of improvements — complicating future renovations or property assessments.

Step-by-Step: How to Research Building Permits

1. Start with the Local Building or Code Enforcement Office

  • Contact the township, city, or county building department.
    • Ask for the permit history or property record file for the specific address.
    • Many municipalities have online permit lookup portals where you can search by address or parcel ID.
  • Request copies of:
    • Building, electrical, plumbing, mechanical, and zoning permits.
    • Inspection reports and final approvals (“finals” or “certificates of completion”).
    • Certificates of Occupancy (CO) or Use & Occupancy permits (U&O).

Tip:
If the township or county maintains a property file (paper or electronic), you can often request to view it under public records laws.

2. Compare Records to What You See

  • Compare the permit history to the current home’s layout and features:
    • Do the square footage, number of bathrooms, or decks/additions match what’s listed on the tax record or old plans?
    • If the home has a finished basement, enclosed porch, or second-floor addition with no permit on record, that’s a red flag.

Examples of warning signs:

  • Permit history stops before a major remodel date.
  • No mechanical or electrical permits for visible upgrades (e.g., new HVAC, wiring, or kitchen layout).

3. Check the Tax Assessor’s Records

  • Look at the property assessment card on the county website or tax office.
    • It lists square footage, year built, and additions/remodel years.
    • If the tax record shows less square footage or older construction dates than reality, there may have been unrecorded (unpermitted) work.

4. Review Past MLS Listings or Real Estate Photos

  • Search for older listings on Zillow, Realtor.com, or Redfin.
    • Compare past photos and floorplans with current conditions.
    • You can often spot added decks, finished basements, or room conversions that weren’t present before.

5. Ask the Seller for Documentation

  • Request:
    • Copies of all permits and final inspections.
    • Invoices or contractor information.
    • As-built drawings or plans if available.
  • If they claim “the previous owner did it,” that increases your due diligence responsibility.

Tip:
Ask your agent to include a clause in the offer that the seller must disclose any unpermitted work to the best of their knowledge.

6. Consult a Qualified Home Inspector or Engineer

  • Hire an inspector experienced with identifying unpermitted or substandard work.
  • Ask them specifically to note:
    • Electrical panels, framing modifications, plumbing reroutes, and HVAC systems that appear newer than the rest of the home.
    • Evidence of concealed or incomplete work.

7. Check Utility Company or Contractor Records

  • Sometimes, utilities or contractors must file notifications (e.g., for new HVAC or water heaters).
  • Ask if the HVAC, electrical, or plumbing contractor pulled permits — reputable ones usually keep copies.

8. Ask the Township About “After-the-Fact” Permits

  • If you find unpermitted work, ask the building department:
    • Whether you can apply for retroactive permits (“as-built” permits).
    • What documentation or inspections would be required.
    • Whether penalties or modifications would apply.

Tip:
Some municipalities allow a “field verification” inspection to legalize existing work — but only if it meets current code.

9. Involve Your Title Company or Real Estate Attorney

  • Title searches won’t always show unpermitted work, but:
    • An attorney can review local ordinances for potential fines or enforcement.
    • They can also ensure your purchase contract includes appropriate disclosure and indemnity language to protect you.

10. Weigh the Findings

If you discover unpermitted work:

  • Estimate correction costs (e.g., tearing down a deck or opening walls for inspection).
  • Negotiate with the seller to:
    • Obtain retroactive permits before closing,
    • Provide credits or price reductions, or
    • Escrow funds to cover future compliance work.